Why You Should Allow Pets in Your Boise Rental Property

March 15, 2024

Boise is a gateway to the outdoors and endless wilderness. This attracts many renters to the area with a love for adventuring, getting outdoors and owning a furry friend. In fact, according to the American Veterinary Medical Association, in 2016 Idaho ranked third in the nation, with 70% of households owning a pet. This was also pre-pandemic which doesn't account for the pet boom of 2020 and 2021. As a Boise property management company rooted in the community, we understand the importance of finding the perfect balance between accommodating furry companions and maintaining your rental properties. So, let's discuss pros, cons and everything you need to know about allowing renters with pets in Boise.

Larger Renter Pool:

In Boise, allowing pets in rental properties can significantly expand your potential tenant pool. With a growing number of pet owners seeking homes that welcome their four-legged friends, allowing pets in rentals opens doors to a broader range of renters. This is particularly important to remember when considering the tenant pool of "quality renters". It's much better to place a quality tenant with a pet than a bad tenant without a pet. The bad tenant will cause you far more problems and costs.


Pet Rent and Pet Deposits:

To mitigate any potential risks associated with pets, implementing pet rent and deposits ensures added protection for Boise landlords. These fees help cover any damages that may occur during a tenant's occupancy, providing peace of mind while accommodating furry residents. It is common to charge refundable and/or non-refundable deposits, sometimes referred to as a pet fee. The average non-refundable deposit or pet fee in Boise is about $200, while the average pet rent in Boise is around $50 per pet, per month.


Happier, Responsible, Long-Term Tenants:

Studies show that pet-friendly rental properties often foster happier, more responsible tenants. Pet owners tend to be more invested in maintaining their living spaces and are generally more responsible. Plus, for many pet owners, finding a rental property that accommodates their beloved companions can be a deciding factor in renewing leases and fostering long-term relationships. So allowing renters with dogs, can enhance tenant satisfaction and increase overall retention rates. If you haven't read our post on the power and importance of tenant retention, read that here.


Allergies and Disturbance to Neighbors:

While pets bring joy to many, it's essential to consider the other tenants affected by allowing pets in rental homes. Balancing pet-friendly policies with respect to neighbors is key, while implementing thorough cleaning protocols between tenants can help alleviate allergy concerns. Clearly outline expectations regarding noise and behavior in pet policies and addendums so as to minimize disturbances and maintain a harmonious living environment for all.


Pet Screening, Policies and Addendums:

Implementing rigorous pet screening processes ensures that only well-behaved animals are welcomed into rental properties. This can include documentation of vaccinations, behavioral assessments, and references from previous landlords. Boise landlords sometimes charge a pet screening fee of about $25 as well as place restrictions on  the age, weight, breed and number of pets allowed. 


Pet policies or addendums are another vital part of the process, once you have decided to allow pets in your Boise investment property. These will outline all the expectations and responsibilities in writing so that any disputes can be handled swiftly. The policies often include vaccination requirements, no history of aggression, photos and description of each pet, etc. These will also be as enforceable as clauses within the main lease. Meaning any breach of the policy, can result in a termination of the lease.


Assistance Animals:

Legally, assistance animals (including emotional support animals) are not considered pets. So, it's important to remember that all policies and procedures put in place will not apply to them. This has been a contentious issue over the years, mainly due to the ease of acquiring the necessary documentation. So much so, that many landlords believe they are forced to allow pets, as tenants will simply apply and receive the certification for their animal, regardless of their needs or disability. Obviously, this is the minority of cases and there has been tightening of restrictions recently. Either way, its important to remember this exception for assistance animals and to not discriminate against applicants or tenants because of their assistance animal.



Embracing pets in Boise rental properties, if done correctly, can be greatly beneficial for landlords. The increased renter pool, higher rent and greater tenant retention are all massive positives. On the other side of the coin, a weaker renter pool, routine checks that tenants aren't sneaking in pets and the lack of protection if they are, means not allowing pets in your rental home may be fighting a losing battle. By implementing thoughtful pet policies and being open and clear, landlords can strike the perfect balance between accommodating furry companions and preserving the state of their properties. So, should you allow pets in your rental? In Boise, the answer is a resounding "yes!"


Are you ready to welcome renters with pets into your Boise rental properties? Contact us today to learn more about creating pet-friendly leasing options that work for you and your tenants.

Disclaimer: This blog post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, tax, real estate, or investment advice. Because laws, regulations, and market conditions change and each situation is unique, you should consult a qualified professional before making any decisions based on this content. Bluebird Property Management makes no guarantee as to the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of the information provided.

Normal wear and tear vs tenant damage in Idaho rental
April 24, 2026
Understand the difference between normal wear and tear and tenant damage in Idaho rentals, with examples landlords can use for deposits and move-out disputes.
Idaho security deposit rules for landlords
April 22, 2026
Learn Idaho security deposit rules, refund deadlines, legal deductions, and best practices for landlords to avoid disputes and protect rental income.
Idaho landlord entry notice before rental inspection
April 21, 2026
Learn Idaho landlord entry notice rules, when owners can access a rental, inspection best practices, and how to protect tenant privacy and compliance.
Idaho eviction process guide for Boise landlords
By Andrew Smith April 15, 2026
Learn how the Idaho eviction process works for Boise landlords, including notices, timelines, court steps, common mistakes, and how to avoid costly delays.
Boise tenant screening guide for landlords by Bluebird Property Management
April 13, 2026
Learn how Bluebird Property Management screens tenants in Boise using income, credit, rental history, references, and fair housing compliant criteria.
Boise rent pricing guide for landlords
April 8, 2026
Learn how to price your Boise rental, handle rent increases, reduce vacancy, and protect long-term returns with a smarter renewal strategy.
Move-in and move-out inspection guide for Boise landlords
February 26, 2026
Learn how Boise landlords can use move-in and move-out inspections, photos, and documentation to avoid security deposit disputes and protect their property.
Boise rental marketing and listing best practices
February 11, 2026
Learn how to market your Boise rental with better photos, pricing, descriptions, platform exposure, and faster lead response to reduce vacancy.
u-haul, migration data, idaho
January 20, 2025
Boise, Idaho, continues to shine as a city of opportunity and growth, even as recent U-Haul migration data shows a slight shift in Idaho’s popularity. Ranked 10th on U-Haul’s list of most popular states people moved to in 2024, Idaho’s drop from 6th place last year raises questions about the state’s evolving appeal. Despite this change, Boise remains a standout destination for residents and investors alike.
boise rent control, boise housing market, boise housing laws, rent control, landlord tenant laws
August 12, 2024
Rent control is a law or local ordinance, introduced by government, that restricts how much a landlord can rent or increase the rent of a residential housing unit. It is a very controversial issue with certain states, including Idaho, banning rent control policies altogether. The goal of rent control is to provide and protect affordable housing amid increasing living costs and stagnant wages. However, this is not always the outcome and many argue that it in fact does the opposite, hurting those that it is looking to protect. Many rent control regulations limit landlords to raising rent by 5%-7% plus the increase in consumer price index (CPI), on an annual basis.
More Posts